Before anyone on my team drafts an email to a journalist, we write the headline the outlet would run if it said yes. Then we write the first two sentences of the story under it, in that publication's voice, for that publication's readers. Only after that do we decide whether there is a pitch to send.
Often there isn't, and finding that out early is the point of the exercise.
My position is that a pitch is a writing problem only at the very end. Most of the work is picturing the finished story from the outlet's side, and most pitches fail because the sender skipped that step and started typing a letter about themselves. Subject line tricks, follow up schedules and templates get a lot of attention in my industry. In my experience they decide very little. The thinking that happens before the email decides almost everything.
What journalists told Muck Rack this year
I try not to lean on my own read of what reporters want when they have said it themselves. Muck Rack surveyed 1,044 journalists between January 30 and March 2, 2026, for its State of Journalism 2026 report, and kept 897 responses after quality checks. Two findings from it shape how I think about a pitch.
First, 78% said a pitch feels relevant when it directly affects the community their audience belongs to. Read that sentence twice. The reporter is asking whether a specific group of their readers is touched by what you are offering, and your credentials come later, if at all.
Second, when asked what they value most in a pitch, journalists named clear relevance to their beat, access to relevant sources, original research or data, and high resolution images. That is a shopping list. Very few of the items on it are adjectives about the person pitching.
Muck Rack sells software to PR teams, so I treat the report as one vendor's survey. It still matches what I see, and it gives a cleaner picture than my opinion would on its own.
Five questions I answer before writing a word
Writing the headline first forces these five questions into the open. If I cannot answer one, I stop.
1. Which outlet, and which section of it? A headline only exists inside a publication. Our network covers 1,600+ publications, and the range is wide, from national business titles to trade outlets that serve one profession. A story that fits a consumer health section will read as noise to a legal trade desk. When people tell me they want "press," I ask them to name the section they read and picture their name in it. Vague targets produce vague pitches.
2. Who in that audience is affected? This is the Muck Rack finding put to work. Name the group. Parents of teenage drivers in one metro. Clinic owners deciding whether to add a new service. Small brands selling online during the holidays. If the honest answer is "anyone who might hire me," the story has no community, and the reporter will see that in the first line.
3. What changed? A headline needs a verb that describes movement. A rule took effect, a cost went up, a common habit stopped working, a client result came in that contradicts the usual advice. "Local firm offers quality service" has no verb doing any work. When I cannot find what changed, I usually do not have news. I have a company description.
4. What can I hand the reporter that they cannot get elsewhere? Look at the shopping list again. A source with direct experience, a small set of original numbers, a clear photo. An owner pitching their own expertise is offering one source, themselves. The stronger move is to offer the reporter what they would have to chase down otherwise, such as data the business has collected, or access to the person on the team who did the work.
5. Would the outlet's editor approve this headline without changing it? I read the outlet's last ten headlines, then read mine next to them. If mine sounds like an ad, or longer, or flatter than theirs, I rewrite it or drop it. The headline is a mirror. It shows you whether you wrote for their reader or for yourself.
Why the exercise saves time
People push back on this because it feels slow. Writing a headline and an opening for a story that may never run seems like extra work.
I think it is the opposite. A pitch built on a clear headline takes ten minutes to write, because you already know what you are asking for. A pitch built on a wish takes an hour of rewording, then goes out to dozens of reporters, then gets silence, then gets a follow up that also gets silence. The slow part of PR is pitching stories that were never stories.
It also keeps you honest about fit. I wrote in Stop asking for Forbes and start asking for a reason that the outlet name is the wrong place to start. The headline exercise is the practical version of that idea. Once you have to write the actual headline a national title would run, you find out fast whether your reason is strong enough for that page or better suited to a trade outlet whose readers care about the detail.
There is a long tail benefit too. Coverage that came from a clear angle tends to describe you clearly, with a specific claim, a specific audience and a specific result. That article then sits in the public record, and it is what a person or an ask AI tool finds when they look you up later. A muddled pitch that somehow lands tends to produce a muddled article, and the muddle stays online. I covered that afterlife in Old press about you still shapes what AI says today.
Where I see owners get stuck
The hardest question on the list is usually the third one. Owners of law firms, clinics, brands and small companies are close to their work, and from the inside, everything feels like news. A new hire, a new office, a new logo. Those matter to the business. They rarely change anything for a reader.
The fix is to look outward. What do you know, because of your work, that the people you serve do not know yet? What did you see happen in the last ninety days that most of your peers have not noticed? Those answers are where headlines come from, and they are often sitting in a client conversation you had last week.
Here is the one thing I would do this week. Pick a single publication you would like to appear in. Open it and copy its ten most recent headlines into a document. Under them, write the headline you would want it to run about your work, matching their length and tone, and then write the first two sentences of that story as their reporter would. If you cannot get through the first sentence without describing yourself, keep the document open and look for what changed. When you find it, the pitch will take ten minutes.



